Can a Neighbor Tear Down a Shared Fence?

Concerned about your shared fence being torn down by a neighbor? Discover the legal rights and options available to you when it comes to disputes over shared boundaries
Veda Yalamanchili
Veda Yalamanchili
Last Update:
April 3, 2024

Boundary fences are more than just a line dividing your yard from your neighbor’s. They can be a source of disputes and headaches if not handled properly. But what happens when your neighbor decides to take down a fence you both share? Or worse - a fence that is in your yard? It’s not as simple as you might think. This blog will guide you through different scenarios, from the moment your neighbor mentions removing the fence, to finding the fence already down one morning. We’ll discuss your rights, responsibilities, and steps to take in each situation. Let’s dive into the world of shared fences and good neighborliness.

Understanding Property Lines and Boundary Fences

When it comes to owning a home, it’s crucial to understand where your property begins and ends. This is where terms like property line, boundary line, and boundary fence come into play.

Property Line or Boundary Line: This is an invisible line that defines the limits of your property. It separates your land from your neighbor’s land. You can usually find the exact details of your property lines in your property deed or on a plat map.

Boundary Fence: This is a fence that is built on or near a property or boundary line. It can be shared between two property owners, or it can be owned by just one property owner, depending on local laws and the specific circumstances.

Knowing your property boundaries is essential for several reasons. First, it helps you respect your neighbor’s space and avoid disputes. Second, it’s important for planning any home improvement projects, like building a new fence or adding an extension to your house. Lastly, understanding your property boundaries can help protect your rights as a homeowner.

Remember, if you’re ever unsure about your property lines or boundary fence, it’s a good idea to consult with a real estate professional or a lawyer. They can help you understand your rights and responsibilities as a property owner.

What is a Shared Fence?

Shared fence

A shared fence, also known as a boundary fence or division fence, is a privacy fence that sits on the property line between two properties. It’s shared in the sense that both neighbors benefit from its presence and, typically, both neighbors are responsible for its maintenance and any other costs related to the fence.

Responsibilities Towards a Shared Fence

When you share a fence with your neighbor, you both have certain responsibilities. These can include sharing the cost of building or repairing the fence, maintaining your side of the fence, and not altering the fence without the other’s consent. It’s important to have clear communication with your neighbor about these responsibilities during the fence installation to avoid any disputes. 

Shared Fence Disputes

Sometimes, despite best efforts, disputes can arise over shared fences. This is where a Homeowners Association (HOA) can play a crucial role. If your property is part of an HOA, they may have rules and regulations about fences, including shared ones. They can mediate disputes and help enforce the rules to ensure that all parties are treated fairly. But what if you are not part of an HOA or your HOA can’t intervene? Here are two scenarios to help you understand what to do in this situation:

Scenario 1: Your Neighbor Talks About Taking Down the Fence

So, your neighbor just mentioned they’re thinking about taking down the shared fence. It’s natural to feel a bit worried or unsure about what to do next. But don’t worry, this is a good opportunity to have a friendly chat and understand each other’s perspectives.

What to Do?

Firstly, don’t panic or get upset. Remember, at this stage, it’s just a conversation. Your neighbor hasn’t taken any action yet. It’s important to stay calm and open-minded.

Having a Friendly Chat

Approach your neighbor and ask if you can talk about the fence. Choose a time when both of you are free and not rushed. During the conversation, listen to their reasons for wanting to take down the fence. It could be because it’s old and worn out, or they might want to put up a new one.

Express your thoughts and concerns politely. If you want the fence to stay, explain why. Maybe it gives you a sense of security, or you like the way it looks. If you’re open to the idea of a new fence, discuss what type of fence you’d both prefer.

Remember, this is a shared fence, so decisions about it should ideally be made together. This initial conversation is the first step toward reaching an agreement that works for both of you.

Scenario 2: Your Neighbor Starts Taking Down the Fence

Imagine you’re enjoying a quiet afternoon at home when you hear some noise outside. You look out and see your neighbor has started taking down the shared fence. You’re surprised because you haven’t agreed to this. What should you do?

What to Do?

First, don’t panic. It’s important to stay calm and not let your emotions take over. Approach your neighbor calmly and ask about what’s happening. There might be a misunderstanding that can be cleared up with a simple conversation.

If your neighbor continues to take down the fence without your agreement, or if you are already too late, it’s time to take further action. Document the situation. Take pictures or videos of the fence before and after it’s taken down. This could be useful evidence later on.

Calling for Help

If talking to your neighbor and reaching out to your Homeowners Association (if you have one) doesn’t resolve the issue, you might need to seek legal advice. Contact a local real estate attorney who specializes in property disputes. They can guide you to small claims court or suggest the best course of action based on local laws and ordinances.

Remember, it’s important to handle this situation calmly and respectfully. It’s not just about a fence, it’s about maintaining a good relationship with your neighbor.

Paying for the Fence After It’s Been Torn Down

Tearing down a shared fence

So, your neighbor has already torn down the shared fence. You’re left wondering: “Who’s going to pay for this?” Let’s talk about how these costs are typically handled in such situations.

Firstly, it’s important to remember that if the fence was shared, the cost of a new fence or repairs to the existing one is usually split between both property owners. However, if your neighbor tore down the fence without your agreement, they might be responsible for the costs of putting it up again.

Legal Issues Around Removing a Neighbor’s Fence Without Consent

In many jurisdictions, removing a shared fence without the consent of the other property owner can lead to legal disputes. The fence is considered joint property, and one party does not have the right to unilaterally remove it. If a neighbor removes a shared fence without your consent, you may have legal grounds to seek compensation for the cost of replacing the fence or even sue for damages.

State Laws and Local Ordinances Affecting Fence Disputes

Laws regarding fence and boundary disputes can vary greatly from state to state, and even from city to city. Let’s take a look at California and Texas as examples:

Adverse Possession and Encroachment

A fence falling down

When it comes to property boundaries and fences, two terms you might come across are “adverse possession” and “encroachment”. These legal concepts can have a big impact on property rights, so let’s break them down.

Adverse Possession

Adverse possession is a legal principle that allows a person to claim ownership of another person’s property if they have occupied it for a certain period of time, without the owner’s permission. This might sound surprising, but it’s a concept that’s been part of property law for centuries.

Let’s say your neighbor builds a fence that’s actually on your property, not theirs. This is called Encroachment If you don’t take action and the fence stays there for many years, your neighbor might be able to claim that strip of your land as their own through adverse possession. The exact rules and timeframes for adverse possession vary by state, so it’s important to check your local laws.

Why Immediate Action is Important

If a fence is built that encroaches on your property, it’s important to take action as soon as possible. This might involve talking to your neighbor, having a surveyor confirm your property boundaries, or seeking legal advice. Taking action early can prevent future headaches, and potential loss of property through adverse possession, and help maintain good relations with your neighbors.

Remember, when it comes to fences and property lines, knowledge is power. Understanding these concepts can help protect your property rights and keep the peace with your neighbors.

In conclusion, the legality of tearing down a shared fence between neighbors depends on various factors such as property rights, local ordinances, and agreements between both parties. Neighbors must communicate and come to a mutual agreement before making any decisions regarding the fence. If there is a dispute, seeking legal advice or mediation may be necessary to resolve the issue peacefully. Ultimately, understanding the laws and regulations in your area is key to avoiding conflicts with neighbors over shared fences. Remember, open communication and respect for each other's property can go a long way in maintaining good neighborly relationships.

Want Your Fence Installed by a Pro?
Let us take care of your fence installation project with no hassle and zero hidden fees. Start with a free quote in just a few clicks: it’s easy and takes just a few minutes
Get a Free Quote